In a significant decision, the Allahabad High Court has stated that while establishing sexual relations by making a false promise of marriage at the very beginning is a crime, refusing to marry after establishing a consensual relationship cannot be considered the crime of rape. The court emphasised that no one can be held guilty unless it is proven that the physical relationship was established based solely on a false promise of marriage.
Key Observations By The Court
Consensual Nature: The court noted that an adult woman established relations twice over a period of four months with her consent. Filing a criminal case merely because a marriage proposal was later rejected does not equate to sexual intercourse obtained through a false promise of marriage.
Lack Of Evidence: The FIR contained no allegations constituting an offense under the SC/ST Act, nor were there any allegations of intimidation.
Abuse Of Process: Under these circumstances, the court observed that continuing the criminal case would be an abuse of the judicial process.
Case Details And Judgment
With these observations, the single bench of Justice Anil Kumar allowed the petition filed by Abhinash Sharma (alias Avinash Sharma) and quashed the criminal proceedings against him.
An FIR had been lodged against the petitioner at the Bilariyaganj police station in Azamgarh, alleging rape under the pretext of a false promise of marriage and offenses under the SC-ST Act.
Arguments And Legal Reasoning
Defense Argument: The petitioner's advocate, Prashant Singh Rinku, argued that even if all allegations were accepted as true, no crime was constituted. He submitted that the victim is an adult, and the sexual relations were consensual, which does not fall under the category of a crime. He termed the remaining allegations baseless.
Prosecution Argument: The government counsel argued that establishing sexual relations through a false promise of marriage is a serious offense.
Court's Stance: Referring to Supreme Court precedents, the High Court stated that a charge of rape must be proven beyond reasonable doubt.
The court highlighted that the victim herself admitted to having sexual relations over four months. However, there was no evidence to suggest that the relationship began based on a promise of marriage. The court ruled that if a relationship is consensual, filing a rape charge later due to a rift or disagreement does not constitute a crime.
