Ahead of the signing of the Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between India and New Zealand on April 27, a remark by a senior minister has sparked controversy. Deputy Leader of the NZ First party and Minister for Regional Development, Shane Jones has criticised the deal for its potential impact on immigration levels. The controversy comes just days before the agreement is expected to be signed in New Delhi.
New Zealand Minister Sparks Racism Row
In an interview with New Zealand’s Reality Check Radio, Jones referred to a possible increase in Indian immigration as a “butter chicken tsunami.” He said, “I don’t care how much criticism we get, I am just never going to agree with a butter chicken tsunami coming to New Zealand.” As the video surfaced online, his comment was widely criticised as insensitive and inappropriate.
Netizens Slam Minister
Netizens called the remark racist, saying it stereotypes Indian culture. A user said, “I agree with western politicians regarding strict immigration policies. Its a reasonable point of view. But normalising usage of racist slurs like curry, " butter chicken" is criminal. There are NZ citizens of Indian race who will face the blunt of this racism.” Another user added, “Hope he doesn’t get caught in that tsunami! You will need butter chicken experts to rescue him.”
As the criticism grew, the minister defended his remarks, saying he uses "hyperbole" to gain "cut through" in public debates. According to 1News, Jones said, “I get cut through on debates by deploying hyperbole.’
What Led Him To Spark Row?
The FTA agreement aims to boost trade between the two countries. Under this deal, India will receive zero-duty access for 100 per cent of its exports to New Zealand, while India will reduce or eliminate tariffs on 95 per cent of New Zealand's exports. Moreover, Wellington is also set to provide a temporary employment visa pathway for 5,000 skilled Indian professionals every year. This provision will allow a maximum stay of 3 years.
India-New Zealand FTA
The agreement is expected to strengthen economic ties with India. Announcing the FTA on December 22, 2025, Prime Minister Narendra Modi had called it a “strong push to bilateral trade and investment.”
He wrote on X, “An important moment for India-New Zealand relations, with a strong push to bilateral trade and investment! My friend PM Christopher Luxon and I had a very good conversation a short while ago following the conclusion of the landmark India-New Zealand Free Trade Agreement. Concluded in just nine months, this historic milestone reflects a strong political will and shared ambition to deepen economic ties between our two countries. This FTA ensures: Enhanced market access, Deeper investment flows, Numerous opportunities for innovators, entrepreneurs, farmers, MSMEs, students and youth."
You May Also Like To Watch: