A week after a scary Flydubai incident mid-air, Israel has tightened the already-in-place restrictions on airline pilots and cabin crew from several countries that do not maintain diplomatic relations with it. The list of the countries whose pilots are barred from entering the Jewish country is long, but the majority of them are Muslim nations.
Israel does not explicilty does not officially describe all Muslims as a threat. Israel has experienced wars, attacks by armed groups and threats from organisations that claim an Islamist ideology. These experiences shape its security policies. However, the actions of particular militant groups do not establish that Muslims generally pose a threat.
Other airlines follow suit
This prompted changes in crew scheduling by international airlines, including Air France and United Airlines.
The move follows an alleged hijacking attempt involving a Flydubai flight bound for Tel Aviv and has raised questions about aviation security, employee rights and the operational challenges facing global carriers.
According to reports, Air France has confirmed that it is complying with Israeli requirements concerning crew members operating flights to and from Tel Aviv. The restrictions reportedly affect individuals holding citizenship, including dual nationality, from countries without diplomatic ties with Israel.
United Airlines has also reportedly incorporated the restrictions into its crew-planning procedures. The airline is said to have instructed affected employees to adjust their assignments in accordance with the requirements. However, the precise scope of the measures and their implementation may vary between airlines.
Why does Israel take such a step?
The controversy intensified following an alleged incident on September 30, involving a Flydubai flight travelling from Dubai to Tel Aviv. An Omani co-pilot attacked the Indian captain and attempted to take control of the aircraft. The incident reportedly triggered renewed concerns about flight safety and the screening of airline personnel.
In another reported case, Israeli authorities allegedly instructed an Ethiopian Airlines flight bound for Tel Aviv to return to Addis Ababa after identifying an Indonesian pilot on board. The pilot was reportedly replaced before the aircraft continued its journey.
The restrictions are said to cover crew members from several countries, including Pakistan, Iran, Oman, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Yemen, Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, Indonesia, Malaysia, Bangladesh and Afghanistan. Algeria, Tunisia and Libya have also been mentioned in reports. However, accounts differ over the total number of countries covered, with some reports referring to 29 countries and others citing a broader list.
Why does Israel's move sound controversial?
The measures have sparked debate over the balance between national security and employment rights. Supporters of stricter screening argue that governments must take appropriate steps to protect aircraft and passengers. Critics, however, warn that restrictions based primarily on nationality could raise discrimination concerns and expose airlines to legal challenges in countries with different employment protections.
For international airlines, the rules could create additional operational complications, requiring changes to crew rosters, flight assignments and staffing arrangements. Such adjustments may also increase administrative costs and make scheduling more difficult on routes serving Israel.
The reported restrictions do not amount to a worldwide ban on Pakistani pilots or other affected nationalities. Instead, they concern eligibility to operate certain flights connected with Israel under the reported requirements.
(With inputs from agnencies)
You may also like to watch