Sanchar Saathi App Controversy: Apple iPhone Devices May Not Comply, Why Apple vs Indian Government?

Sanchar Saathi App in iPhone: A government directive requiring the Sanchar Saathi app to be pre-installed on all smartphones sold in India has ignited a fresh debate. The move is presented as a push against cyber fraud and stolen devices, but the uncertainty around whether the app is optional or mandatory has already drawn scrutiny. More importantly, it sets the stage for another potential confrontation between Apple and Indian regulators — very similar to the 2016 dispute over TRAI’s spam-reporting app.

Is Sanchar Saathi Mandatory or Not?

The Department of Telecommunications’ circular leaves room for confusion. Under this directive, smartphone makers must ship devices with Sanchar Saathi already preloaded, and users will not be allowed to disable or remove it. Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia has publicly indicated they can. An updated directive clarifying this contradiction is still pending. Even so, brands are expected to add the app to new devices and possibly older inventory via software updates.

ALSO READ: OpenAI Project ‘Garlic’ Codename: Early Tests Show Strong Performance Against Rivals

For most Android OEMs, this becomes another compliance exercise. But for Apple, the implications run deeper.

Sanchar Saathi App Controversy: Why is this different for Apple?

Apple’s iPhones ship without pre-installed third-party apps — a principle tied to privacy, security and user control. Accepting a mandated app sets a precedent that Apple may not be able to walk back. Sanchar Saathi also requires system-level access to features like the camera, call logs and messages — access that iOS architecture is specifically designed to restrict.

The company has already been reported to be weighing a resistance strategy. According to Reuters, Apple is prepared to tell the government that pre-installation conflicts with its security policies and that it does not comply with similar demands elsewhere.

Apple vs Indian Government: This is not the first time

India and Apple have been here before. Nearly a decade ago, TRAI wanted its “Do Not Disturb” app on the App Store to tackle spam calls. Apple pushed back until both sides agreed on a compromise: instead of allowing the app to read user logs, Apple built a native reporting layer inside iOS. Expect a similar negotiation this time — not full compliance, but an alternative approach that lets Apple preserve its ecosystem rules while giving the government the functionality it wants.

High-Stakes Negotiation

Apple has become increasingly significant to India's economy over time. Now assembling billions worth of iPhones locally and making significant export contributions while rapidly growing retail and manufacturing operations, India requires Apple as a growth story; Apple needs India as an alternate base beyond China.

ALSO READ: Google Android 16 Update: Brings AI Notification, And Summaries, Checkout Eligible Devices

Neither party benefits from a public standoff. More likely, Apple offers a software-level solution that incorporates Sanchar Saathi’s verification and tracking features without a full-fledged app sitting on the home screen.

As it stands now, Apple remains in confusion, and both parties are quietly positioning themselves for what may turn out to be forced compliance with India's cyber safety agenda without jeopardising Apple's strict privacy boundaries.