The Delhi High Court has acquitted a man who was accused of outraging the modesty of a woman by calling her ‘gandi aurat’ (dirty woman) in a workplace dispute. The court said that the words, without any other context or gesture, did not amount to an offence under section 509 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
The court observed that gender-specific laws are not meant to be biased against the opposite gender, but to address the unique issues faced by a particular gender in society. It said that judges should not be influenced by gender-related factors when administering justice unless there are specific presumptions in favour of a particular gender in law.
“Gender-specific legislation exists to address the unique concerns and challenges faced by particular genders within society. However, this does not imply that the judge is to be influenced or swayed by gender-related factors when administering justice unless specific presumptions are legislated in favour of a particular gender in law. In essence, judicial neutrality is an indispensable cornerstone of the legal system, ensuring that all parties, regardless of gender, are treated fairly and equitably,” Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma said.
Recommended For You
The court set aside the order of a trial court that had framed a charge against the man under section 509 IPC, which deals with word, gesture or act intended to insult the modesty of a woman. The prosecution had alleged that the man, who was the senior of the woman in the same organisation, had used foul language against her when she refused to give him Rs 1,000.
The court said that the word ‘gandi aurat’, if read in isolation, without context, without any preceding or succeeding words indicating intent to outrage the modesty of a woman, will not bring these words within the ambit of section 509 IPC.
“Had there been any mention of any other words used, context given or any other gesture etc. made accompanying, succeeding or preceding these words, reflecting criminal intent to outrage the modesty of a woman, the outcome of the case would have been different,” the court said.
The high court stated that the criminal justice system in India is based on the principle of adversariality, but this does not mean that it is a contest between men and women as such.
“Instead, it should solely revolve around two individuals: one being the complainant and the other being the accused irrespective of gender, however, at the same time, while adjudicating the cases firmly remembering and appreciating the social context and situation of a particular gender who may be in a lesser advantageous situation than the other,” the bench stated.
The high court observed that after looking into the act of the man, it was clear that he did not have the necessary intention or knowledge to infer that his use of the term ‘gandi aurat’ would amount to outraging the modesty of a woman by a reasonable person’s standard.